Siesta Key is a popular destination for travelers who appreciate coastal living, sugar-white sands, and exceptional dining. With the Gulf just steps away, the island delivers some of the freshest seafood on Florida’s west coast. Whether you’re booking a short getaway or an extended stay in one of the many Siesta Key condo rentals, these seafood restaurants in Siesta Key provide a delicious way to enjoy the area’s coastal flavors.
From casual oyster bars to refined seafood and steak houses, Siesta Key offers a variety of dining experiences that pair well with the convenience of Siesta Key luxury condo rentals and the comfort of Siesta Key beachfront condo rentals.
Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar
Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar has become a staple of the island dining scene thanks to its longstanding reputation and welcoming, family-friendly environment. Located near Crescent Beach, it’s a convenient stop for guests staying in Siesta Key beachfront condo rentals. The laid-back setting makes it a popular choice for families, while the fresh seafood and drinks offer something for everyone. It’s also an excellent option for large groups looking to dine together after a day of outdoor adventure.
Siesta Key Oyster Bar
Siesta Key Oyster Bar is a well-known spot for fresh oysters and relaxed dining in the heart of Siesta Key Village. Its casual, open-air environment and consistent service make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With live music and a welcoming setting, this restaurant is ideal for guests staying in nearby Siesta Key condo rentals who want to enjoy the local atmosphere without traveling far. It’s an easy choice for groups looking for a laid-back dinner after a day at the beach.
Walt’s Fish Market Restaurant
A short drive from Siesta Key, Walt’s Fish Market Restaurant offers an authentic seafood dining experience with a focus on fresh, locally sourced fish and shellfish. Guests often make the trip from their Siesta Key luxury rentals to enjoy the well-known quality and laid-back charm of this long-established spot. With a history of serving the Sarasota area for generations, it’s an excellent option for anyone wanting a more traditional seafood experience close to the island.
The Old Salty Dog Siesta Key
Located near the waterfront, The Old Salty Dog is a casual restaurant known for its marina views and unfussy atmosphere. It’s a favorite for travelers looking to relax in an outdoor setting after a day on the water or beach. Whether you arrive by foot or boat, it offers an easy, no-frills seafood experience that still delivers quality and consistency.
Plan Your Visit
Ready to try these incredible Siesta Key seafood spots for yourself? Browse our full inventory of Siesta Key luxury rentals to find the perfect place for your visit!
Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood
Siesta Key Summer House Steak & Seafood brings a more refined approach to the local seafood scene. Its upscale interior, attentive service, and curated wine list make it ideal for guests celebrating special occasions or simply looking for an elevated dining experience. Just a short distance from many Siesta Key luxury rentals, it’s a convenient choice for those who want to enjoy a polished meal in a contemporary setting without leaving the island.
Book a Siesta Key Condo Rental with Ten 35 Seaside Rentals
Pairing your Siesta Key dining experience with the right accommodations can elevate your vacation from enjoyable to exceptional. At Ten 35 Seaside Rentals, we offer a collection of premium Siesta Key condo rentals designed to meet the needs of today’s travelers. From spacious Siesta Key luxury condo rentals to well-located Siesta Key beachfront condo rentals, our properties deliver both comfort and convenience. With high-end amenities, responsive service, and prime locations across the island, Ten 35 makes it easy to enjoy everything Siesta Key has to offer, especially its celebrated seafood scene.
